If you were to do a comprehensive survey of some sort, I suspect that you would find that this site gets a lot more of its stories from Slashdot or Warren Ellis than from, say, Daily Kos or Talking Points Memo.
Shocking! Well, what better occasion than William Shatner's 74th birthday* to begin to correct that imbalance?
And so, it is from Taegan Goddard's invaluable Political Wire that we learn of a Baltimore Sun profile of Diana Schaub, a Loyola College Professor of Political Science and member of George W. Bush's President's Council on Bioethics, an august advisory body charged with guiding the President's views on weighty matters of national policy which don't involve lowering the Capital Gains Tax rate or invading anyone (yet).
The Council is chaired by Dr. Leon Kass, a Harvard and Chicago-educated medical doctor and molecular biologist who is a professor in the rather ominously-named Committee on Social Thought and the College at the University of Chicago. Among his other qualifications, Dr. Kass famously wrote, in The Hungry Soul: Eating and the Perfecting of Our Nature,
"Worst of all from this point of view are those more uncivilized forms of eating, like licking an ice cream cone - a catlike activity that has been made acceptable in informal America but that still offends those who know eating in public is offensive."
...which leads one to be thankful that he was not put in charge of the FDA or Department of Agriculture, at least.
For what it's worth, in the very next paragraph after that curious statement, he tackled
other deep stains on the human character, saying
"Not just the uneducated rustic but children of the cultural elite are now regularly seen yawning openly in public," before continuing on to target
"...sneezing, belching, and hiccuping and even the involuntary bodily display of embarrassment itself, blushing."Nevertheless, Dr. Kass is, indisputably, a doctor and a molecular biologist. By contrast, one may well wonder about the qualifications of Professor Schaub, who is neither an Ethicist
nor a Biologist, to sit on the President's Council on Bioethics. Well, thanks to the
Sun, we can now rest easy, secure in the knowledge that she has turned for guidance to two impeccable sources of wisdom: Abraham Lincoln and
Star Trek.
She did keep her two influences separate, however, so we don't have to worry that she was talking about "
The Savage Curtain," at least. Because basing national policy on the results of a battle between Good and Evil staged by a powerful lava creature would just be
silly, wouldn't it? Plus, it's a
third season episode — one of the very last, in fact — and we all know what
that means.
No, we can all rest easy on
that account — her touchstone for moral guidance on issues of scientific research is "
Miri" — a first season episode about a planet full of children left orphaned for centuries by the results of a disastrous medical experiment designed to prolong the normal lifespan. The experiment killed all of the adults on the planet while simultaneously slowing down the aging process for all of the children to a crawl.
Now, before you go making fun of the poor woman for basing her views on scientific ethics around (a) a politician who wrote nothing whatsoever on the subject and died before antibiotics, and (b) a
Star Trek episode which features a centuries-old prepubescent girl putting moves on Captain Kirk; consider this: Not only was this episode the screen debut of
Phil Morris, who went on to play "Jackie Chiles" on
Sienfeld; but it
also featured the screen debuts of
Dawn Roddenberry,
Lisabeth Shatner,
and Melanie Shatner, making it, like, the
Star Trekiest episode of
Star Trek ever.
Finally, if
Richard Perle,
Paul Wolfowitz, and
Douglas Feith had leaned on
Star Trek for inspiration, would we have ever dared to
interfere in the affairs of a pre-warp civilization?
*Most of this was written on Shatner's birthday, at least. Anyway, he's Canadian, and their days are, like, equal to 18 of our hours, right?